Analysis of collaborative design and decision making through argumentation applied for pre-BIM stages.

Leon, Marianthi; Toniolo, Alice

Abstract

The early design stages are the most vital for the development of the design of a building project and the decisions taken during these steps are significant for the further progress of the project, regarding aspects like cost, performance, reliability and sustainability. Being able to trace backwards the thoughts that led to these decisions at any point of the design process provides clarity and transparency during the decision making process. Additionally, monitoring the design steps and decisions can lead to further observations on the effects of the design decisions during the early design stage, thus leading to a more sustainable and holistic design approach. This paper claims that efficient monitoring of the decision steps can be achieved employing a computational model of argumentation. Argumentation-based reasoning helps identify the rationale for a decision (i.e. arguments) and the relationships (i.e. attacks and preferences) between conflicting issues involved in making decisions. Our approach provides a method to rigorously trace the resolution of conflicts by extracting the set of acceptable arguments that led to a decision, and may eventually assist designers in analysing complex collaborative decisions within a pre-Building Information Modelling context. This paper was presented at the International Conference on Building Information Modelling (BIM) in Design, Construction and Operations, held in Bristol, 9-11 September 2015.

Citation

LEON, M. and TONIOLO, A. 2015. Analysis of collaborative design and decision making through argumentation applied for pre-BIM stages. In Mahjoubi, L., Brebbia, C.A. and Laing, R. (eds.) Building information modelling (BIM) in design, construction and operations: proceedings of the 1st International conference on building information modelling (BIM) in design, construction and operations, 9-11 September 2015, Bristol, UK. WIT transactions on the built environment, 149. Southampton: WIT Press [online], pages 217-228. Available from: https://doi.org/10.2495/BIM150191

• Presentation Conference Type: Conference Paper (published)
• Conference Name: 1st International conference on building information modelling (BIM) in design, construction and operations
• Start Date: Sep 9, 2015
• End Date: Sep 11, 2015
• Acceptance Date: Sep 9, 2015
• Online Publication Date: Sep 30, 2015
• Publication Date: Dec 31, 2015
• Deposit Date: Oct 19, 2015
• Publicly Available Date: Oct 19, 2015
• Publisher: WIT Press
• Peer Reviewed: Peer Reviewed
• Pages: 217-228
• Series Title: WIT transactions on the built environment
• Series Number: 149
• Series ISSN: 1743-3509
• Book Title: Building information modelling (BIM) in design, construction and operations
• ISBN: 9781845649142
• DOI: https://doi.org/10.2495/BIM150191
• Keywords: Collaborative design; Argumentation; Pre BIM; Decisions; Conflicts
• Public URL: http://hdl.handle.net/10059/1317
• Contract Date: Oct 19, 2015