Skip to main content

Research Repository

Advanced Search

Participants or pretenders? Addressing the challenge of inauthentic participation in academic research in the UK: experiences from the FIO and DIO Food research teams. [Preprint]

Hunter, Emma; Stone, Rebecca A.; Greatwood, Hannah C.; Johnstone, Alexandra M.; Griffiths, Claire; Crabtree, Daniel R.; Douglas, Flora; FIO Food Team; DIO Food Team

Authors

Rebecca A. Stone

Hannah C. Greatwood

Alexandra M. Johnstone

Claire Griffiths

Daniel R. Crabtree

FIO Food Team

DIO Food Team



Abstract

Individuals participate in research for numerous reasons, however, the global economic downturn may have driven some to participate solely for monetary recompense. While inauthentic participation is more widely recognised in quantitative survey studies, it is increasingly becoming an issue in qualitative research. Drawing on our experiences and supported by the wider literature, we highlight ways in which inauthentic participation can be identified and addressed. We argue it is pertinent researchers are aware of the risks and potential impact of inauthentic participants and recommend researchers consider this phenomenon from study planning stages onwards. We identify Universities and ethics committees as well placed to provide training and ensure, where necessary, mitigation plans are in place before granting study approvals. We suggest funders and publishers request inauthentic participation be considered and reported. These recommendations would establish awareness, prevent wasting valuable project resources, increase transparency of reporting and ensure data integrity is protected.

Citation

HUNTER, E., STONE, R.A., GREATWOOD, H.C., JOHNSTONE, A.M., GRIFFITHS, C., CRABTREE, D.R., DOUGLAS, F., on behalf of the FIO and DIO Food Team. Participants or pretenders? Addressing the challenge of inauthentic participation in academic research in the UK: experiences from the FIO and DIO food research teams. [Preprint]. Hosted on OSF: Centre for Open Science [online]. Available from: https://doi.org/10.31219/osf.io/gzfxh_v1

Working Paper Type Preprint
Online Publication Date Feb 1, 2025
Deposit Date Jun 23, 2025
Publicly Available Date Jun 26, 2025
DOI https://doi.org/10.31219/osf.io/gzfxh_v1
Keywords Inauthentic participants; Imposter participants; Data integrity; Data validity and reliability; Research methods
Public URL https://rgu-repository.worktribe.com/output/2675717

Files




You might also like



Downloadable Citations