Taming trilogues: the EU's law-making process in a comparative perspective.
Greenwood, Justin; Roederer-Rynning, Christilla
As the directly elected institution of representative democracy, the European Parliament (EP) is at the centre of debates about the nature of the EU polity. The dramatic increase in its legislative powers since becoming a directly elected institution in 1979 makes it the central object of analysis about the development of the European Union. At the core of its powers is its role as a co-legislator with the Council of Ministers for the overwhelming majority of legislative files since the 2009 Treaty of Lisbon, making the mechanics of co-decision a key unit of analysis. The core question we address in this chapter is whether the EP, the people’s tribune in EU politics, has arrived at a stable set of arrangements in order to be able to assert itself in co-decision viz. other EU institutions. Trilogues present two potential risks for the EP as an organ of parliamentary representation: 1) depoliticizing conflict by delegating decision-making to technical experts; and 2) reducing the accountability and transparency of the decision-making process by making it more informal and ad hoc. The key for the EP to counter these risks is to develop a sense of common purpose as a parliamentary institution, and institutional autonomy to prevent being drawn into the Council’s world of diplomacy. On these premises, we explore the extent to which the EP has been able to articulate procedures for internal conflict solving; and to what extent these rules have helped to ensure transparency of the legislative process and the accountability of elected representatives. We examine these factors through an examination of the internal mechanisms of the EP in preparing for co-decision, trilogues, as a critical moment of the institutionalisation of the EP as a legislature. We discuss these developments in a comparative perspective of EU and US institutions for bicameral conflict resolution.
GREENWOOD, J. and ROEDERER-RYNNING, C. 2019. Taming trilogues: the EU's law-making process in a comparative perspective. In Costa, O. (ed.) The European Parliament in times of EU crisis: dynamics and transformations. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan [online], pages 121-141. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-97391-3_6
|Online Publication Date||Nov 24, 2018|
|Publication Date||Nov 24, 2018|
|Deposit Date||Apr 26, 2019|
|Publicly Available Date||Nov 25, 2020|
|Publisher||Palgrave Macmillan (part of Springer Nature)|
|Book Title||The European Parliament in times of EU crisis: dynamics and transformations.|
|Chapter Number||Chapter 6|
|Keywords||European Parliament; European Union; Trilogues; Decision making; Institutionalization|
GREENWOOD 2019 Taming trilogues
Publisher Licence URL
You might also like
Inside the black box of trilogues: introduction to the special issue.
Organized interests and trilogues in a post-regulatory era of EU policy-making.
Trilogues in council: disrupting the diplomatic culture?
Black boxes and open secrets: trilogues as 'politicised diplomacy'.