Skip to main content

Research Repository

Advanced Search

Perspectives of crisis intervention for people diagnosed with 'borderline personality disorder': an integrative review.

Warrender, Dan; Bain, Heather; Murray, Ian; Kennedy, Catriona

Authors

Heather Bain

Ian Murray



Abstract

What is known on the subject? - People diagnosed with 'BPD' often experience crisis and use services 'BPD' is a controversial diagnosis, and the experience of crisis and crisis intervention is not well understood. What this paper adds to existing knowledge? - People diagnosed with 'BPD' have different experiences of crisis, and using the diagnosis alone as a basis for deciding care and treatment is not appropriate There are many human factors which can influence how professionals deliver care to people diagnosed with 'BPD'. What are the implications for practice? - The education of staff, views on responsibility, team conflicts and access to clinical supervision can have an impact on how care is delivered, and should be addressed by organizations providing crisis care. Access to care often occurs when a person is self-harming or suicidal, but does not address underlying distress. Crisis care should go beyond managing behaviour and address any underlying needs. Abstract: Introduction 'Borderline personality disorder' ('BPD') is associated with frequent use of crisis intervention services. However, no robust evidence base supports specific interventions, and people's experiences are not well understood. Aim: To explore the experiences of stakeholders involved in the crisis care of people diagnosed with 'BPD'. Method: Integrative review with nine databases searched January 2000 to November 2017. The search filtered 3,169 titles and abstracts with 46 full-text articles appraised and included. Results: Four themes were constructed from thematic analysis: crisis as a recurrent multidimensional cycle, variations and dynamics impacting on crisis intervention, impact of interpersonal dynamics and communication on crisis, and balancing decision-making and responsibility in managing crisis. Discussion: Crisis is a multidimensional subjective experience, which also contributes to distress for family carers and professionals. Crisis interventions had limited and subjective benefit. They are influenced by accessibility of services, different understandings of 'BPD' and human dynamics in complex decision-making, and can be experienced as helpful or harmful. Implications for practice Subjectivity of crisis experiences shows limitations of the diagnostic model of 'BPD', emphasizing that interventions should remain person-centred. While thresholds for intervention are often met after self-harm or suicidality, professionals should review approaches to care and support people with underlying distress.

Citation

WARRENDER, D., BAIN, H., MURRAY, I. and KENNEDY, C. 2021. Perspectives of crisis intervention for people diagnosed with 'borderline personality disorder': an integrative review. Journal of psychiatric and mental health nursing [online], 28(2), pages 208-236. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1111/jpm.12637

Journal Article Type Review
Acceptance Date Apr 2, 2020
Online Publication Date May 5, 2020
Publication Date Apr 30, 2021
Deposit Date Apr 14, 2020
Publicly Available Date Apr 14, 2020
Journal Journal of psychiatric and mental health nursing
Print ISSN 1351-0126
Electronic ISSN 1365-2850
Publisher Wiley Open Access
Peer Reviewed Peer Reviewed
Volume 28
Issue 2
Pages 208-236
DOI https://doi.org/10.1111/jpm.12637
Keywords Borderline personality disorder; Emotionally unstable personality disorder; Personality disorder; Crisis; Crisis intervention; Therapeutic relationship; Health services; Integrative review
Public URL https://rgu-repository.worktribe.com/output/894850